If you struggle with binge eating, you’ve likely heard of Brain Over Binge at some point. You’ve probably seen reviews of Brain Over Binge as well. But have you ever heard a Registered Dietitian do a book review of Brain Over Binge? No? Look no further, you’re in the right place.
In my years working as a binge eating dietitian, I’ve talked with many, many women who struggle with eating disorders. Many of those involve compulsive overeating (or binge eating), and they’re ready for a way out. Brain Over Binge boasts an unconventional, revolutionary path to recovery…. But does it pass my test of being helpful, or is it ultimately harmful?
Whether you have tried it before, you have not tried it but you’re curious, or you’ve never heard of it but are curious about how to overcome a food addiction – this book review of Brain Over Binge is going to answer a lot of questions for you. Let’s dive in.
What Is Brain Over Binge?
Brain Over Binge is a self-help book written by Kathryn Hansen. Hansen formerly struggled with bulimia nervosa and found conventional eating disorder treatment and/or traditional therapy to be unhelpful. In Brain Over Binge, she discusses how a book targeted for substance abuse disorder (aka ‘addiction’) recovery to provide the missing link she needed to quit binge eating… well, cold turkey.
The main premise or philosophy behind Brain Over Binge is that binge urges are simply “neurological junk” coming from the lower brain or animal brain (which I assume is referring to the limbic system). Per this philosophy, you shouldn’t need to address all the ‘why’ behind binge urges because it’s just a voice from the “animal brain” we can simply… ignore.
Brain Over Binge is available in a variety of formats, from a podcast to specific coaching and courses, but is most notably known for being a book (and as of 2022, a workbook).
Who Created Brain Over Binge?
Kathryn Hansen, the author and creator of Brain Over Binge, says that she “stopped binge eating for good in 2005” on her website. She shares in her book that her experience in traditional therapy was unhelpful and ultimately made her bulimia worse. She takes an official stance of “disagreeing” with many components of traditional eating disorder treatment, such as:
- “I do not believe binge eating is the result of underlying emotional or psychological issues.
- I do not believe you need years of therapy in order to stop binge eating.
- I do not believe you need to follow a strict meal plan or give up any “addicting” foods.
- I do not believe you need to learn to deal with triggers, dig into your past, manage all of your feelings, or undergo a personal transformation to recover.”

Is she on to something here? Or is this crazy talk?
In Hansen’s book, she shares a deep sense of frustration over the “conventional route”. She leaves you with the sense that she paved her own way and her experiences in any therapies did nothing to help – it was all her.
Hansen is not a professional or expert in binge eating recovery, eating disorders, or psychology in any capacity. She is not a dietitian, psychologist, therapist, doctor, or even a certified coach (not that it would mean much if she was). She is someone who struggled with bulimia aka has lived experience, then decided she figured out how to cure it in a way that no one else has ever considered before.
From a marketing perspective, it’s brilliant: the ‘you’ve been lied to’ angle paired with the ‘I have the magic solution’ pitch. Not quite snake oil, but close.
But let’s be clear about something: lived experience is powerful. But it is no substitute for clinical training or evidence-informed practice. What works for someone is not going to work for others. In fact, it may be downright harmful for others. Any side-steps away from the status quo of treatment need to be made safely and under the guidance of a licensed, trained professional(s) who can navigate the nuances of recovery.
Let’s step off the credentials soapbox for a moment and play devil’s advocate. Does Hansen have any leg to stand on with the points she makes in Brain Over Binge?
Understanding the Brain Over Binge Program
The components of Brain Over Binge, though claiming to be an unconventional route to stop binge eating, actually share a lot of conventionally known and taught truths. Let’s take a look at the overarching themes, principles, and components of Brain Over Binge.
Brain Over Binge Principles
- Binge urges come from the “lower brain.”
One key component is to “View Urges to Binge as Neurological Junk”, or faulty messages rather than unmet needs that must be uncovered and satisfied. Binge urges are nothing more than a habit coming from the lower brain (i.e. limbic system), not the higher self (i.e. frontal lobe). For those who have studied the psychology of behavior change, this isn’t anything new.
- You can choose not to act on them.
Assuming binge urges are nothing more than the product of a habit created in the lower brain, the second component is to “Separate the Higher Brain from Urges to Binge”, and the third component to “Stop Reacting to Binge Urges”. In other words, see it as a separate voice and one that you don’t need to listen to, and don’t make a big deal out of it. No judgement, shame, or self-hate.
Again, this isn’t anything new. These are technically techniques commonly used with binge eating recovery: Acceptance Commitment Therapy (ACT) and Dialectal Behavior Therapy (DBT). She even notes this in her book that separation techniques are not new and are used often in the eating disorder ecosystem of treatment/recovery. Why then, is she acting like her breakthroughs are unheard of in eating disorder therapy? She’s using conventional treatment techniques while discouraging conventional treatment techniques. It makes no sense.
- Eat adequately.
One thing Brain Over Binge is clear about is that restrictive dieting, white knuckling, and sheer willpower are not the answer to binge eating. The author encourages balanced, regular eating and to not undereat. I can hear all the dietitians and eating disorder professionals saying it now: “Amen!”
- The recovery goal is simple: stop bingeing.
Try not to be too shocked when I share that the main goal of recovery in Brain Over Binge is to stop binge eating. What a revolutionary idea (I know. I’m losing my patience, and it’s showing. It’s only going to get worse from here, unfortunately). More specifically, Brain Over Binge encourages all other life issues to be put to the side and to focus instead on cessation of binge eating. I can get on board with that, and I’m sure other “conventional” treatment providers would as well.
How to Access the Brain Over Binge Program
The Brain Over Binge program spans multiple formats:
- Books: Brain Over Binge (the memoir-style book) + Recovery Guide (a workbook developed from the memoir).
- Podcast: a free option that covers the principles and stories.
- Course: an online curriculum that offers structured lessons, Q&A recordings, and worksheets.
- Coaching: one-on-one or group with Hansen or trained coaches.

Does Brain Over Binge Work?
You might be surprised to hear that a Registered Dietitian (Hi! That’s me) from the world of “CoNvEnTiOnAl TrEaTmeNt” actually sees a lot of good in this book.
For one, it does offer a great deal of hope to those who have a long, treacherous track record of binge eating. It makes it seem like binge eating is no big deal at the end of the day, something we can simply switch off. It gives a sense of control (and we looooooove control).
Brain Over Binge helps validate the reader. They’re understood, not ostracized. Hopeful, not defeated. Reparable, not broken. The author sees the reader and (metaphorically) says: “Hey. This doesn’t define you. You can beat this.” And, who doesn’t love that?
It’s also somewhat straightforward. There are not a lot of layers to this approach. In many ways, that’s a downfall because it misses the other needs of many. But I can also acknowledge the beauty in simplicity. We generally do like the path of least resistance, after all.
Something Brain Over Binge does RIGHT that most other “methods” do WRONG is actually encourage the individual struggling with bingeing to eat adequately. Ahhhh! Music to my ears. Finally, someone (other than me and my like-minded colleagues) gets it! Outlawing foods and being chronically underfed is. not. helpful. and. reinforces. the. problem.
Lastly, it’s great how accessible the resources are. The books are low-cost, the podcast is free, and the courses / coaching is relatively low-cost as well.
The Problems with Brain Over Binge
Now, the problems with Brain Over Binge. I feel a bit like Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde here, but some things must be said. Here we go…
Oversimplification
Many online reviews (and past/present clients of mine) agree that Brain Over Binge is a bit like being told “Just don’t binge”. It ignores the complexity that is oftentimes wrapped up into binge eating such as trauma, emotions, neurobiology, restriction, and shame. Many of these topics are touched on in the book, but in a way that is more passive. There’s a passing acknowledgement that those factors may exist without any real coping or tools to help solve them.
Potential for shame
When we frame a relapse as just ‘not resisting hard enough’ or ‘not separating yourself enough from the animal brain’ like Brain Over Binge does, it can make someone feel a bit embarrassed or let down by themselves for – once again – not being able to stop binge eating.
Minimizing emotions
With the very anti-therapy and oversimplified tone of this book, Brain Over Binge minimizes many of the complex emotions, coping, and trauma that often drive binge urges. To the author’s point, there can be a point where it is more habit-driven (i.e. the reward system circuitry creating a learned behavior) than trauma-driven, but that doesn’t mean these (emotions, trauma, coping) things don’t exist or shouldn’t be given a fair shot of examination.

Limited scientific backing… actually….
Funnily enough, many of the modalities for overcoming binge eating shared in Brain Over Binge are a part of traditional / conventional treatment. Acceptance Commitment Therapy (ACT) and Dialectal Behavior Therapy (DBT) are well-studied interventions for binge eating.
The problem is that Hansen is not presenting these modalities in an evidence-informed way and is getting many concepts confused or misunderstood. Therefore, the Brain Over Binge process itself is limited in its scientific backing.
Quick-fix feel
Though Hansen claims to be against quick-fixes, she’s also evidently against long term recovery (see her direct quotes under the heading “Who Created Brain Over Binge”). In the end, the overall tone of “just stop it, you don’t need to talk about it with someone” is landing a bit quick-fix-y.
Not trauma-informed
Brain Over Binge may not and likely won’t suit people with co-occurring mental health challenges (depression, PTSD, anxiety, etc).
May discourage people from getting professional help and support
Brain Over Binge brings an overwhelming sense of “this vs conventional treatment”. Let’s examine why this is preposterous.
“In therapy, I learned that self-control wasn’t enough, that I needed to develop alternative coping skills or to fulfill my emotional needs instead. Yet when the urge to binge arose, it always seemed like none of that matter and nothing else but food would do.”
– Kathryn Hansen, Brain Over Binge (2nd edition)
The author shares that she had an epiphany while reading a recovery book meant for alcoholics. She realized, for the first time, that her binges were like an addiction where she had learned to relieve cravings and get temporary pleasure through binge eating. Brain Over Binge argues that there is no unmet inner needs behind binge eating behaviors, like traditional therapy might imply. Rather, it’s as simple as being a habit.
She goes on to say that she couldn’t control her thoughts or feelings around food that were originating in the “animal brain”, which is why she found it so hard to stop. Confusingly, she says even though she couldn’t talk her animal brain out of these demands, she didn’t have to follow its lead. Rather, she just needed to use her “human brain” to control her actions.
Which, wouldn’t that be… talking herself out of the “animal brain”’s demands then? Admittedly, I’m getting quite confused by her logic at this point in the book. What she has just described is using the prefrontal cortex (area of the brain responsible for things like decision making, planning complex behaviors, moderating social behavior, etc) to override the more primitive part of the brain known as the limbic system.
Hilariously, she shares that the night she stopped binge eating was the night she “decided I would just let my thoughts and feelings about food surface, then observe them as if they were not coming from me. Then I would not do what they told me to do.”
This, my friends, is a well-known technique called Acceptance Commitment Therapy (ACT) and has been around since before Hansen’s epiphany that “conventional therapy doesn’t work”.
What she describes doing the night she stopped binge eating for good is a well-known technique called “riding the wave of an urge”. This isn’t unique or unconventional—it’s actually extremely conventional.
She goes on to say that she was using bingeing to cope with the urge to binge, as if this was a revolutionary discovery that no therapist or eating disorder professional could have ever understood. Unless she had truly terrible professionals over and over and over again (she noted in her Note to Reader that in total she consulted 3 mental health counselors, two psychologists, three nutritionists, a psychiatrist, and a medical doctor), this isn’t groundshaking. At least not in 2025, maybe it was 20 years ago though.
She found it extremely healing to have found “the root cause” to her binge eating being simply the urge itself.
“I binge because I had urges to binge…
…This was not the answer I expected to find after all those years of therapy. I expected the answer to be far more complex, possibly related to my past, my depression, my social anxiety, my brain chemicals, or my personality.”
– Kathryn Hansen, Brain Over Binge (2nd edition)
Well, here’s the thing. The answer is brain chemicals. Ironically, the limbic system, which Hansen alludes to quite a bit (the “animal brain”), is the reason for this.

A quick lesson on reward circuitry signaling in the brain:
We release dopamine when we eat. We also release it when we engage in any other life-sustaining behaviors (drinking, exercise, procreation, etc). The amount can vary though, and when we experience something that releases a higher amount of dopamine than normal (like the initial binge after a year and a half of dieting, such as the author experienced), our brain learns (through this chemical) that this behavior should be repeated because it felt good. Here’s the reward system circuit in oversimplified terms:
- Brain likes dopamine.
- Brain listens carefully to when dopamine is released.
- Brain thinks anything that releases high amounts of dopamine is necessary for sustaining life.
- Brain works to remember the things that released the dopamine so the behavior can be repeated.
- Brain drives us to repeat that behavior (hence: the urge).
How does one overcome binge eating behaviors when it’s become a reward system problem? We have to unlearn the learned responses/behaviors and override. Ironically, this is precisely the point Hansen is making in this book. I fear she doesn’t understand her own arguments. That’ll likely be because she isn’t properly educated on the topic.
It’s unfortunate that Hansen did not learn ACT or how to ride the wave of an urge through the professional help she sought out. She should have, and maybe she did, but for whatever reason, it wasn’t the right time. It’s also unfortunate that no one explained the reward system of the brain to her because clearly, that would have resonated with her. But make no mistake – her methods are not new, noteworthy, or unconventional: They’ve just been mislabeled as so.
In the end, what this is doing is turning many people away from getting traditional help like psychotherapy, where ACT can be deployed as a part of the treatment process, along with any other methods necessary for the individual’s case.
To her credit, Hansen had the foresight to add this clause in the Note to the Reader:
“In this book, I’ll explain why I disagree with many aspects of conventional talk therapy for eating disorders and popular theories about how to recover, but this should never discourage you from seeking medical or nutritional support, or any other form of professional help you feel is necessary.”
-Kathryn Hansen, Brain Over Binge (2nd edition)
Unfortunately, this is a bit pointless. Despite the author’s disclaimer, Brain Over Binge ultimately discourages many readers from seeking professional help.
Unsurprisingly, online feedback about Brain Over Binge shows mixed outcomes. Some succeed, others relapse (now with added shame because they feel it was supposed to be so easy to just stop), and others feel unsupported when urges resurface. Those who succeed are likely the ones who are responding well to the ACT or DBT techniques the book is providing (without realizing it).
How Brain Over Binge Compares to Other Recovery Models
Brain Over Binge is unknowingly recreating similar tenants to other traditional recovery models. Let’s take a look at a few of the popular ones.
Brain Over Binge vs. Intuitive Eating
Intuitive Eating (IE), created by two eating disorder dietitians, encourages moving away from restrictive dieting and examining where weight/shape concerns may have been more about societal influence rather than true biological necessity. IE encourages mindfulness and reconnecting with early signs of hunger and fullness while reframing any “forbidden” foods to be something that is up for grabs whenever it’s worthwhile.
Brain Over Binge loops in some similar sentiments with its discouragement of restrictive dieting. However, it does not provide information from the lens of a nutrition expert for best practices to fuel oneself as we shift away from restrictive dieting, and how to create a normal relationship with food that is not based on good foods vs bad foods.
Brain Over Binge vs. Eating Disorder Therapy
Despite what the book may lead you to believe, Brain Over Binge is actually similar to traditional eating disorder therapy in many ways. Picture eating disorder therapy being a bucket full of puzzle pieces that are in disarray. When treating a patient, the traditional model will utilize whatever puzzle pieces necessary to create 1 full picture of recovery. Brain Over Binge took out 1 or 2 of those puzzle pieces and is now claiming they are unique, unheard, and even discouraged in traditional eating disorder treatment. This is not true.
That is why there are many mixed reviews for Brain Over Binge. Some individuals needed the exact puzzle pieces the book provides. Others found them to be needed pieces for their puzzle, but not all of the pieces to make a complete picture. Others didn’t need those pieces for their puzzle at all.
Brain Over Binge vs. Dietitian Support
Brain Over Binge doesn’t talk much about getting support from a dietitian. A comment is made in the intro notes that when the word “therapy” is used in the book, it is meant as a sweeping term to loop in all the different professionals utilized during the author’s attempts to heal in traditional treatment, including (but not limited to) three different nutritionists. I would imagine those were Registered Dietitians, but I’m not sure.
Had Hansen seen a Registered Dietitian who specializes in binge eating (such as myself), things may have gone very differently. Maybe she did and they just weren’t very good. Or even still, maybe they were phenomenal but it just wasn’t the right time in Hansen’s journey to hear the same things that she later read in the book she picked up on substance abuse recovery. It’s tough to say.
Regardless, working with a binge eating dietitian should cover everything Brain Over Binge is hitting on and more – depending on the puzzle pieces you are in particular need of.
Having a dietitian on your side for binge eating recovery is crucial to ensure that regular eating patterns are established (which is a gold-standard, first line defense against binge urges ever arising to begin with).

Common Questions About Brain Over Binge
Does Brain Over Binge really work?
It can work for some people by offering hope, simple strategies, and techniques similar to Acceptance Commitment Therapy (ACT) or Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT). However, it often oversimplifies binge eating and doesn’t meet everyone’s recovery needs.
Is Brain Over Binge safe?
It may be safe for individuals with mild binge eating who resonate with its approach, but it can also discourage professional help and leave people feeling ashamed if it doesn’t “work,” which makes it potentially risky and can worsen binge eating behaviors.
Is Brain Over Binge scientifically proven?
No, Brain Over Binge is based on one woman’s recovery story and borrows from established therapeutic methods, but it has not been validated in clinical trials or research studies.
Who can Brain Over Binge help?
It may help people who benefit from straightforward, habit-focused tools and who feel encouraged by Hansen’s message that binge urges don’t define them.
Who might it not work for?
It’s less likely to work for those with trauma histories, co-occurring mental health conditions, or complex emotional drivers behind binge eating since the program minimizes these factors and discourages therapy.
The Verdict: Brain Over Binge Dietitian Review
Q: Is Brain Over Binge legit?
A: Not really.
Q: And is it helpful, or harmful?
A: Honestly, it can be both.
Explanation:
The overarching premise of this book is essentially that traditional therapeutic methods to stop binge eating are trash. The author speaks as if she’s discovered a hidden link between why binge eating starts (survival instincts) and why it persists (as a learned response in the limbic system, or “animal brain”). She presents her solution as if no eating disorder treatment could have ever provided it:
- Distance yourself from the “animal voice” (what providers in the eating disorder space call the ED voice), and
- Lean into your “human voice” (aka your true self).
The problem? These are actually well-known, widely used techniques in eating disorder treatment—specifically Acceptance Commitment Therapy (ACT) and Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT). That’s why Brain Over Binge can feel helpful to some: it touches on real strategies that work. But it can also be harmful because it frames these as the only solution, discouraging people from exploring other vital pieces of recovery. And when it doesn’t “work,” people are left feeling defeated, ashamed, and with nowhere else to turn (especially after being swayed by the book’s vocal dismissal of traditional treatment).
At the end of the day, Brain Over Binge might provide a few puzzle pieces, but it’s not the whole picture. Recovery from binge eating is nuanced, and what helps one person may be exactly what another person doesn’t need.
If you’re ready for a comprehensive, evidence-informed approach that doesn’t rely on one-size-fits-all fixes, I invite you to take my free mini course. In it, you’ll get a taste of how I help women quiet food noise, stop binge eating, and build a healthy relationship with food using hands-on support that creates space for personalization. In the mini-course, you’ll see how my clients go from feeling trapped in slavery to food to finding lasting relief in 4 months or less.
