How to Eat Like a Normal Person (and Build a Healthy Relationship With Food)

by | Oct 30, 2024 | Relationship With Food

Something that comes up a lot in my conversations with individuals struggling with food is that they wish that they could just eat like a normal person. 

They’ll tell me things like:

  • “I wish I could just approach food like a normal person and not let it run my life.” 
  • “I want to be able to not think about food constantly and just live my life normally without that voice in the back of my head always wanting food.”
  • “I want to live a normal life with food without a constant diet.”
  • “I’d like to not think about food and all the rules and just be normal around food.”
  • “I need to be able to have a normal life around food. It’s destroying my emotions and hope.”

If you’re reading this, then there’s a good chance you’ve also experienced some of these thoughts and feelings. You’ve probably felt like there’s a sense of normalcy with food that some people have and that you’re missing out on.

But what does eating like a normal person even mean? Keep reading to learn more about “normal” eating habits and what stops so many of us from having a good relationship with food.

The short answer: Eating like a “normal person” means having a healthy relationship with food: you eat when you’re hungry, stop when you’re satisfied most of the time, enjoy the foods you like without guilt, and think about food only a normal amount. You get there by eating consistently, letting go of rigid food rules, and working on the thoughts and beliefs that keep food loud, not by finding the perfect diet.

What Is Normal Eating?

One of the hardest parts of learning how to eat like a normal person is that “normal” is relative. What may seem normal to one person could be anything but normal to another. And thanks to diet culture, many of us see things like restricting calories or following food rules as “normal” eating behaviors.

As an intuitive eating dietitian who helps people struggling with binge eating, I talk about the idea of “normal eating” constantly.

One of my clients recently described it really well while talking about how her husband eats.

She said, “I realized a couple of years ago that my husband doesn’t really think about food that often. He eats when he is hungry and he thinks about what he is in the mood for or feels like he wants. I was honestly flabbergasted. I don’t think I had ever really processed that food didn’t need to take up 90% of my brain space.”

This is such a good example of a “normal” relationship with food and also highlights what so many individuals (women especially) struggle with when it comes to normal eating: thinking about food constantly.

a person's hands cutting up a bowl of fried eggs and vegetables

What a Healthy Relationship With Food Looks Like

Over the years, I’ve come up with my own definition of normal eating. To me, it looks like:

  • Eating when hungry
  • Stopping when full
  • Eating what you’re in the mood for without guilt or worry
  • Mindfully opting for foods that make you feel good
  • Not obsessing about food

Normal eating can also include:

  • Occasionally overeating or emotionally eating
  • Sometimes eating less than normal

For many people, this is the exact opposite of what their relationship with food looks like. If you’re one of these people, you might:

  • Eat regardless of how you feel physically
  • Not notice fullness unless you’re so sick you can’t physically bear having any more to eat
  • Avoid the foods you crave and find yourself bingeing later
  • Feel extreme worry, guilt or stress over your food choices
  • Spend most of your time thinking about food (including what you’re going to eat, when, how much, if it’s okay to eat it, how you shouldn’t have eaten something you did before and what other people are eating)

If you’ve experienced this kind of obsession over food – even if you think it’s an obsession over healthy eating – then you know exactly what I’m talking about. It’s constant food chatter or food noise taking up space in your brain.

In other words, normal eating and a healthy relationship with food are the same thing. Food is part of your life, not the center of it.

Signs of an Unhealthy Relationship With Food

An unhealthy relationship with food doesn’t have to look dramatic. For most of my clients, it looks like a lot of quiet effort that never seems to pay off. You might recognize yourself in a few of these:

  • You think about food constantly, even right after eating (this is food noise)
  • You label foods as “good” or “bad,” and yourself along with them
  • You feel guilty or anxious after eating certain foods
  • You cycle between “being good” and binge eating, often at night
  • You use food to cope with stress, boredom, or exhaustion more often than you’d like
  • You feel out of control around certain foods, so you keep them out of the house
  • Your mood for the day depends on the number on the scale

If several of these sound familiar, nothing is wrong with you. These patterns are learned, usually through years of dieting, and they can be unlearned.

So why does this happen? Why is it so hard for some of us to just eat normally? 

What Keeps Us From Eating Normally?

There are many reasons you might struggle to adopt and maintain normal eating habits. And often, diet culture is at the heart of it.

Perhaps you’re constantly dieting and trying to lose weight. Maybe you’re restricting foods or entire food groups. Maybe you’re purposefully ignoring your hunger signals, or you did at one point and now you’ve lost them completely. You might feel like you know how you should be eating to support your health, but you struggle to make the nourishing choice.

A recent client conversation illustrated this perfectly. She was telling me that she finds it hard to “do the right thing” when it comes to her nutrition. She knows what the more nourishing choice is, but she struggles to choose it. Instead, she reaches for less nourishing foods and then doesn’t feel great after eating them.

As humans, we often view this as a personal failing – a simple lack of willpower. But it’s not that simple. 

Instead, it comes down to the way our brains think about food and nutrition. There’s the more logical side of the brain that is more deliberate, intentional and has long-term goals in mind. Then, there’s the part of the brain that’s more emotional. 

And you know what makes it super hard to tap into the logical part of your brain? When you’ve got a whole bunch of emotional junk clouding up your ability to reason through anything else. 

I think of it like driving in the rain. The rain coming down on the windshield makes it hard to see and make the right driving decisions. But when you use your wipers to wipe the rain off the window, you can see better and more easily get to your destination safely.

A woman smiles at the camera while eating salad in a kitchen

Our emotions – specifically stress – are like rain coming down and making it harder to make the right decisions.

If you struggle with food noise, negative self-talk, being down on yourself, or constant thoughts of food… that’s a form of stress. When that stress is going on, you have less access to the part of your brain that’s more logical and deliberate.

To put it simply, you’re literally unable to make “normal” decisions about food! 

I talk through this in more depth on the podcast in Episode 66:

So, what can we do to fix this situation and learn how to eat like a normal person? It starts by going to the root of the problem.

How to Build a Healthy Relationship With Food: 6 Steps

Often, when I work with a client who is struggling to eat normally, they try to overcome this issue by forcing themselves into a certain style of eating.

You’ve probably done this too. Maybe you’ve decided to follow a diet, gotten a meal plan from your trainer or just decided to have more willpower. In reality, adopting these kinds of food rules is the worst thing you can do if you struggle with normal eating.

Why? Because trying to follow food rules or go against your brain’s true desires around food actually adds on more stress. 

You may be able to force your way through “normal” eating for a few days, weeks or even months. But eventually, all that stress will overpower your brain’s ability to think logically and you’ll find yourself back to emotional eating, overeating and even binge eating.

This is why the best way to learn how to eat like a normal person doesn’t involve any food rules. Instead, you need to get into the weeds of your relationship with food and change the thoughts, beliefs, and values systems you have. This is how you can alleviate food stress instead of piling onto it. 

When we get deeper into the roots of what’s causing that stress, that’s when everything falls into place.

Remember that client who was talking about how her husband only eats when he’s hungry, stops when he’s full, and eats what he’s in the mood for without worrying about it?

A month and a half after working together to dig into her specific relationship with food and identifying the source of her chronic food stress, she shared this with me:

“We had friends over last night for pizza and I didn’t stress about what I ate. I had a couple slices and some fruit and felt comfortably full and moved on. One of my daughter’s friends had leftover cupcakes from her birthday that they brought to our house and left. I had one and then they just have been sitting in the kitchen and I didn’t go eat any “in secret” later, or even think about doing that. (Typically I would have either not eaten any in front of people or would have had one and then gone back for more when no one was around.)”

Because we corrected the misalignments in her relationship with food and with her body that were creating more stress, she was suddenly able to “eat like a normal person.”

A person uses a fork and a spoon to eat pasta

1. Eat consistently, and eat enough

Your body can’t trust food if it never knows when the next meal is coming. Regular meals with protein and fiber are the foundation everything else is built on. My episode on hunger and fullness cues explains why.

2. Notice your food rules

Write down every rule you follow about food: no carbs after 6, dessert only on weekends, never finish the plate. You don’t have to break them all at once. Just notice how many there are and how much space they take up.

3. Take the power out of “forbidden” foods

The foods you restrict are the foods that call to you the loudest. Bringing them back in a calm, planned way, like a cookie with lunch instead of a sleeve of cookies at 10 PM, takes away their urgency.

4. Separate food from your worth

A “bad” food day doesn’t make you a bad person, and the scale is not a grade. When the stakes come down, the noise comes down. If the weight keeps coming back, this step matters most.

5. Build other ways to cope

If food is your main way to rest, celebrate, or decompress, it will stay loud. Add one or two non-food tools you can reach for, and practice them when you’re not in a crisis.

6. Work on the beliefs underneath

This is the step most diets and coaches skip. The thoughts you have about food, your body, and what you “should” do drive your behavior far more than any meal plan. Changing them is what makes normal eating feel natural instead of forced.

What About Food Freedom?

Food freedom is what this looks like when it’s working. It doesn’t mean eating anything, anytime. It means no food has power over you. You can have the brownie or skip it, and both choices feel like no big deal. That’s what my clients mean when they say they finally feel normal around food.

Keep Going: Relationship With Food Guides

Understand what’s going on

Let go of the diet mindset

When eating feels out of control

Listen

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a healthy relationship with food?

A healthy relationship with food means you eat when you’re hungry, stop when you’re satisfied most of the time, enjoy foods you like without guilt, and spend most of your day thinking about things other than food. It doesn’t mean eating perfectly.

What are the signs of an unhealthy relationship with food?

Common signs include constant thoughts about food, labeling foods “good” or “bad,” feeling guilty after eating, cycles of restricting and overeating, eating to cope with stress, and feeling out of control around certain foods.

How long does it take to heal your relationship with food?

It varies. Many people notice food feels quieter within a few months of eating consistently and dropping rigid rules. Changing long-held beliefs about food and your body usually takes longer, and support speeds it up.

Is food freedom the same as eating whatever you want?

Not quite. Food freedom means no food has power over you. You can have dessert or skip it, and either choice feels like no big deal. Most people who reach it naturally eat a balanced mix of foods because nothing is forbidden, which creates more clarity around needs vs wants.

Ready to Eat Like a Normal Person?

So what does all this mean for you? It means that if you also find yourself wondering how to eat like a normal person, then you can absolutely learn how to do it!

A healthy relationship with food doesn’t come from a better diet book, a macro app, or more willpower. It comes from changing what’s happening underneath.

If you’re ready to start eating like a normal person, then it’s time to start working on your relationship with food. And there’s no better place to do that than in my Nourished & Free program. 

This four-month group coaching program is for anyone struggling with binge eating, emotional eating or chronic dieting. If you can’t stop thinking about food and want to learn how to eat “normally,” then this is for you. Learn more about Nourished & Free and apply to have me and my team support you in your journey to “normal” eating.

Not sure you’re ready for the full program? Get started with my free Food Noise Exit Plan masterclass.